Same News | Different Views

Pop CulturePublished 5 outlets

Harry Shum Jr. Honors Late Glee Costar Naya Rivera on Dancing With the Stars Semifinals

JULIANNE HOUGH, HARRY SHUM JR., JENNA JOHNSONPhoto: Variety
The full story

Harry Shum Jr. paid tribute to his late Glee costar Naya Rivera during Tuesday night's Dancing With the Stars semifinals, performing a quickstep to Valerie and blowing a kiss toward the sky. The same night, Shum and partner Jenna Johnson were eliminated, leaving five couples for next week's Season 35 finale. Shum and Rivera had sung the Amy Winehouse hit together in Glee's second season, and Rivera died in 2020 at age 33. Shum told the judges, “We miss you, baby girl,” and said the song meant a lot to many Glee fans. The pair earned 30 out of 30 for that routine and another 30 for a paso doble to Rihanna and Calvin Harris's “We Found Love.” Deadline's recap noted that six couples had entered the semifinals, each dancing two routines.

Rolling Stone, the left-leaning source, leads with the tribute, quoting Shum's remarks that Glee changed his life, and does not mention the elimination. Variety and Deadline, the alternative sources, treat the moment within the semifinals: Variety's headline spotlights the tribute, while Deadline's recap centers on a perfect-score couple going home. Page Six, the right-leaning source, leads with the elimination, calling it a shocking exit of a fan-favorite duo, and lists the five remaining couples and their scores; its excerpt does not mention the tribute. The sides agree on the routine, the song and the elimination; they differ in emphasis, with tribute on the left and departure on the right.

How the sides differ Left source stresses Shum's tribute to Rivera; right source leads with the couple's shock elimination; alternative sources cover both.

Headline, comparison and summary written by AI from the articles below. AI can make mistakes, so check the original articles before relying on a detail.

Word choice

The words each side uses for the same thing, taken from their articles.

  • the coupleLeft “his professional dance partner Jenna Johnson”Right “fan-favorite dance duo”
Left Rolling StoneWatch Harry Shum Jr. Honor ‘Glee’ Costar Naya Rivera on ‘Dancing With the Stars’

Rolling Stone leads with Shum's emotional tribute to Rivera, using his on-air and on-stage words. It does not mention the couple's elimination.

Right Page Six‘Dancing With the Stars’ sends another fan-favorite couple home during shocking Semi-Finals elimination

Page Six leads with the "shocking" elimination of a "fan-favorite" duo and lists the remaining couples' scores. Its excerpt does not mention the tribute.

How we sort sources into left, alternative and right →

Which coverage felt most fair?

One tap. No account needed.