SportsPublished Oct 21, 2026, 4:38 PM ETUpdated Oct 21, 2026, 5:50 PM ET7 outlets

Giants to start J.J. McCarthy over Jameis Winston at quarterback against Houston

By Crosswire News · AI-assisted summary of reporting by the outlets linked below

Image from CBS Sports's coverage: Giants plan to start JJ McCarthy vs. Texans in Week 7

The full story

The New York Giants will start J.J. McCarthy at quarterback Sunday against the Houston Texans in Houston, replacing Jameis Winston, according to an ESPN report Wednesday. Coach John Harbaugh and players are expected to address the decision after Wednesday's practice. Winston had started the previous four games after Jaxson Dart was injured. In the Giants' 34-27 loss to the New Orleans Saints, McCarthy, acquired from Minnesota in a late-September trade, threw for 243 yards and led multiple scoring drives after replacing Winston. The Giants, at 3-2-1, lead the NFC East and have a bye week after the Texans game. Winston has completed 57% of his passes for 957 yards, with seven touchdowns and five interceptions this season.

Alternative and independent outlets, including ESPN and CBS Sports, report the plan and Harbaugh's comment that the team is still "honing in on a decision," while noting McCarthy's flashes of promise and the injuries that limited him with Minnesota. Left-leaning outlets, including CBS News and The New York Times, lead with the benching and highlight McCarthy's greater mobility against Winston's familiarity with the offense. Right-leaning outlets, including the New York Post, frame the move as bold, emphasizing McCarthy's 243 fourth-quarter yards and Winston's two second-half interceptions.

How the sides differ Left sources stress McCarthy's mobility and Winston's benching; right sources call the move bold, citing McCarthy's fourth-quarter numbers; alternative sources report the plan.

Headline, comparison and summary written by AI from the articles below. AI can make mistakes, so check the original articles before relying on a detail.

Left · 2 sources CBS NewsGiants going with J.J. McCarthy as their starting quarterback

The New York TimesGiants name J.J. McCarthy starting QB, bench Jameis Winston

Leads with the benching and McCarthy's mobility, pointing to his limited familiarity with the offense and the Giants' first-place standing. Relies mainly on the ESPN report and team statements.

Alternative · 2 sources ESPNGiants to start McCarthy over Winston at QB this week against Texans

CBS SportsGiants plan to start JJ McCarthy vs. Texans in Week 7

Leads with the report of the starting decision and Harbaugh's comments on the process. Features McCarthy's flashes of promise and the injuries that limited his Vikings tenure.

Right New York PostGiants to start J.J. McCarthy against Texans in massive QB shakeup

Leads with the move as a bold shakeup, stressing McCarthy's fourth-quarter production and Winston's recent interceptions. Focuses on the challenge of facing Texans coach DeMeco Ryans.