Same News | Different Views

WorldPublished Updated 11 outlets

Vatican Confirms Pope Leo XIV Cast Mail-In Ballot in Illinois Ahead of U.S. Midterms

Illustration: Aïda Amer/Axios. Photo: Rocco Spaziani/Archivio RoccoSpaziani/Mondadori Portfolio via Getty ImagesPhoto: Axios
The full story

The Vatican confirmed Friday that Pope Leo XIV, the Chicago-born former Cardinal Robert Prevost, submitted a mail-in ballot in Illinois for the U.S. midterm elections, making him the first pope known to vote in an American election. The Holy See press office said he has voted as a U.S. citizen whenever he was eligible, including during his years in Peru, and that he believes in the right and duty of citizens to take part in democratic processes. The Will County clerk's office said he requested the ballot on Oct. 3 for his registered New Lenox address. Reports on the request first appeared before the Vatican statement, and elections are set for Nov. 3, with early voting open in most states. The 71-year-old pope is recovering from surgery to remove a lower lobe of his right lung after a lung cancer diagnosis, and the Vatican said he will still travel to Uruguay, Argentina and Peru in early November.

Left-leaning CBS News leads with the historic first and the Vatican's statement, quoting it at length, then adds his recovery from cancer surgery, the South America trip, his brother John's Rome visit with New Lenox parishioners, and a papal call to abandon passivity and indifference. Right-leaning outlets give more weight to his voting record. The Washington Examiner stresses that he requested a ballot and that the clerk's office did not say it was returned, and notes his past Democratic and Republican primary ballots and his brother's support for Trump. The New York Post, which also reports the Vatican confirmation, adds that records show five primaries since 2000, two Democratic and three Republican, and that it is unclear how the ballot was returned. Both sides cite the Chicago Sun-Times and the Oct. 3 request. Axios and BBC largely track the same facts; the BBC adds the pope's clashes with the Trump administration.

How the sides differ Left sources stress the Vatican's civic-duty statement and the pope's health and travel; right sources focus on his voting history, party primaries and how the ballot was returned.

Headline, comparison and summary written by AI from the articles below. AI can make mistakes, so check the original articles before relying on a detail.

Share
Left · 2 sources CBS NewsPope Leo becomes first pontiff to vote in a U.S. election

CBS News leads with the Vatican's confirmation and its civic-duty statement, adding the pope's cancer surgery recovery, upcoming trip, his brother's Rome visit and his remarks against passivity.

Alternative · 2 sources AxiosPope Leo XIV becomes first pope to vote in U.S. election

Axios and BBC report the Vatican confirmation and the first-ever distinction. Axios cites WJOL's early report, while BBC adds his tensions with the Trump administration and the midterm stakes.

Right · 2 sources Washington ExaminerPope Leo XIV requested a ballot to vote by mail in 2026 elections

The Washington Examiner and New York Post emphasize his voting history, including Democratic and Republican primary ballots, and uncertainty over how the ballot was returned, citing the clerk's office and state records.