Same News | Different Views

Midterms 2026Published Updated 8 outlets

Justice Department Sends Target Letters to About 20 Democrats in Alaska Senate Candidate Probe

A sample ballot in Anchorage showing Daniel J. Sullivan Jr. appearing above the Republican incumbent, Dan S. Sullivan, in the state’s Senate race.Photo: The New York Times
The full story

The Justice Department has sent letters to about 20 Democrats telling them they could be targets of its investigation into the recruitment of a second Alaska Senate candidate named Dan Sullivan, according to people familiar with the matter. The letters went out as Alaskans voted Tuesday in a close race between Republican Sen. Dan Sullivan and Democrat Mary Peltola. Recipients include elections lawyer Marc Elias, whose firm has represented Peltola, and at least one Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee official. One source said investigators are examining possible donor fraud and conspiracy charges. It is unclear when the letters were sent or whether all recipients got them. A source told Fox News Digital that the department began the probe in July, has issued more than 120 subpoenas, and that some letters were also preservation notices. Attorney General Todd Blanche said the candidate is running only to confuse voters. President Trump said Elias should go to jail and said Chuck Schumer and Elias should be held criminally responsible. Elias called the inquiry a sham and said he would not be intimidated. Democrats deny wrongdoing.

The New Republic and The New York Times, on the left, lead with the unusual timing of the letters on Election Day and with Democratic accusations that the department is being weaponized. Both note Democrats' argument that recruiting candidates, called ballot stacking, is common and not clearly illegal under state law. They feature Trump's remarks about Elias and Schumer, and The New Republic adds his Truth Social posts suggesting the candidate was missing or kidnapped. Fox News, on the right, frames it as an election spoiler probe, uses the nickname "Decoy Dan," and leads with the letters, the 120-plus subpoenas, FBI visits to donors, and Blanche's claim of fraud on the ballot. It gives little space to the Democratic argument about legality. Both sides agree on the roughly 20 letters, Elias as a recipient and the donor fraud and conspiracy angle. Al Jazeera's coverage stands out for quoting Elias's statement at length, while CNBC highlights a civil rights lawyer's warning about threats to democracy.

How the sides differ Left sources stress the timing and Democratic claims of political weaponization; right sources stress officials' fraud allegations, subpoena numbers and the 'Decoy Dan' label; alternative sources add Elias's response.

Headline, comparison and summary written by AI from the articles below. AI can make mistakes, so check the original articles before relying on a detail.

Share
Left · 2 sources The New RepublicTrump DOJ Targets Democrats in Senate Race Probe Right Before Election

The New Republic and The New York Times lead with the Election Day timing, Trump's calls to jail Elias, and Democrats' charge that the department is being weaponized, noting ballot stacking is not clearly illegal.

Alternative · 2 sources Al JazeeraUS Department of Justice expands its probe into Alaska’s US Senate election

Al Jazeera quotes Elias calling the probe a sham on Election Day and describes what target letters mean; CNBC features a Legal Defense Fund counsel warning of threats to democracy.

Right Fox NewsTrump admin puts alleged 'Decoy Dan' conspirators on notice in Alaska election spoiler probe

Fox News frames the story as a probe of 'Decoy Dan' spoiler conspirators, citing the 120-plus subpoenas, FBI donor visits, a former prosecutor, and Attorney General Blanche's fraud claim.