Same News | Different Views

WorldPublished Updated 7 outlets

Chinese Brands Drop Kylian Mbappé After Video Calling Mao Zedong a Dictator; He Apologizes

Image from The Guardian's coverage: Kylian Mbappé apologises after being dropped by Chinese brands for Mao Zedong commentPhoto: The Guardian
The full story

Chinese brands including Dongpeng Beverage, Inner Mongolia Mengniu Dairy and cheese maker Milkground said Tuesday they were ending ties with France captain Kylian Mbappé after an online video in which he apparently called Mao Zedong a dictator. The 27-year-old Real Madrid forward was speaking about internet memes that portray him as an authoritarian figure. Dongpeng, in a Weibo statement, and Mengniu said in similarly worded announcements that they have zero tolerance for words or actions that hurt the feelings of the Chinese people, and they ended all cooperation immediately. Jokes about Mao, China's founding leader who died in 1976, are considered disrespectful there. Dongpeng had run AI-generated images of Mbappé in adverts during this year's World Cup. La Liga apologized and distanced itself from his remarks. Mbappé then apologized to everyone his words had upset, calling his comment ill-judged.

The Guardian and NBC News, on the left, both carry the company statements and Mbappé's apology. The Guardian's headline leads with the apology, notes the video only appears to show the remark, and adds that Mao jokes are a social taboo and that Mbappé's fans call him Guigui. NBC's headline stresses memes and fury, and its text casts the episode as a clash with fervent Chinese nationalism and sensitivities little understood abroad, with La Liga's apology featured. Newsmax, on the right, leads with the break itself. Its headline says the remark was about a Chinese dictator, it counts at least three companies, and it stresses ads in subway stations and elevators. The portion available does not mention the apologies, La Liga or the nationalism framing. All agree on the remark and Tuesday's terminations. ESPN's coverage resembles Newsmax's, while the Yahoo Sports item covers a different topic.

How the sides differ Left sources stress Chinese nationalism, the Mao taboo and the apologies; right sources stress the brands cutting ties and the reach of his advertising.

Headline, comparison and summary written by AI from the articles below. AI can make mistakes, so check the original articles before relying on a detail.

Share
Left · 2 sources The GuardianKylian Mbappé apologises after being dropped by Chinese brands for Mao Zedong comment

The Guardian and NBC News lead with the brand exits and Mbappé's apology, quoting Dongpeng and Mengniu statements. They add context on the Mao taboo, Chinese nationalism and La Liga's apology.

Alternative · 2 sources ESPNChinese brands drop Mbappé after comment about 'Chinese dictator' meme

ESPN reports that brands dropped Mbappé over comments apparently about a Chinese dictator meme, noting his ads across China. The Yahoo Sports item is about a Ballon d'Or claim, not this event.

Right

Not covering this story. None of the right-leaning outlets Crosswire tracks has reported it yet. What one side leaves out can be as telling as what the others report.