Same News | Different Views

Pop CulturePublished 5 outlets

Fincher directs Tarantino's Cliff Booth sequel, with Brad Pitt returning as the stuntman

Image from The Guardian's coverage: The Further Mis-Adventures of Cliff Booth review – Tarantino and Fincher join forces for Brad Pitt’s glorious returnPhoto: The Guardian
The full story

Brad Pitt returns as stuntman Cliff Booth in The Further Mis-Adventures of Cliff Booth, a spinoff of Once Upon a Time in Hollywood written by Quentin Tarantino and directed by David Fincher. The film arrives on Netflix on Dec. 23 after an IMAX release on Nov. 25, and it is set eight years after the original. Booth now works odd jobs in a less glamorous Hollywood and sometimes solves problems for entertainment figures. His latest case comes through agent Karen Crosby, played by Elizabeth Debicki, who represents actor Charlie Peters, played by Scott Caan. While working in the Philippines, Charlie accidentally orders a hit on his wife, Toni, played by Carla Gugino. The Verdusco brothers will not walk away from their payday unless Booth can persuade them otherwise. Running times in the reviews range from 140 to 143 minutes.

The New York Post, the right-leaning outlet here, opens with a blunt verdict that the film is long and pointless. Its review calls it an unnecessary, ambling, fun-free spinoff and dwells on a clash of styles, with Fincher's murky dreariness set against Tarantino's violent crime comedy. It spotlights the Verdusco brothers' sledgehammer killings and a scene where a woman repeatedly hits Pitt, and it sums up the pairing with the line “That’s like asking a coding expert to fix your plumbing.” The Guardian, the left-leaning outlet, is far warmer, calling the film an energetic, scabrous black comedy and praising Pitt's amiable good nature. It faults the pedantic repeats and truncated ending, and it notes that the film tactfully skips the question of Booth's marriage, which it says the forthcoming Tarantino novel may answer. The alternative sources diverge: /Film offers a spoiler-free guide to whether a post-credits scene exists and notes Fincher's exit from his Netflix deal, while The A.V. Club's headline says the film mis-fires and it describes a grittier Los Angeles. The clearest clash is over whether the film is fun at all, and the sides agree on the cast, Fincher's direction and the Netflix release.

How the sides differ Right sources call the sequel pointless; left sources praise its energy and black comedy; alternative sources focus on plot and Fincher's grit.

Headline, comparison and summary written by AI from the articles below. AI can make mistakes, so check the original articles before relying on a detail.

Word choice

The words each side uses for the same thing, taken from their articles.

  • the filmLeft “outrageous sugar-rush sequel”Right “unnecessary, ambling, fun-free spinoff”
  • Fincher's visual styleLeft “a huge amount of energy, fun”Alt “gray, gritty Hollywood”Right “murky dreariness”
Left The GuardianThe Further Mis-Adventures of Cliff Booth review – Tarantino and Fincher join forces for Brad Pitt’s glorious return

The Guardian frames the film as a glorious, energetic return for Pitt, praising its black comedy while noting its gaps and ending. It leans on the critic's enthusiasm rather than on plot details.

Alternative · 3 sources /FilmDoes Brad Pitt's Cliff Booth Movie Have A Post-Credits Scene? A Spoiler-Free Guide

/Film frames the film as a spoiler-free guide with a post-credits question and Fincher's Netflix exit. The A.V. Club's headline says the film mis-fires, while its text describes a grittier Hollywood.

Right New York Post‘The Further Mis-Adventures of Cliff Booth’ review: Tarantino and Fincher deliver a long and pointless Brad Pitt sequel

The New York Post frames the film as a pointless, self-indulgent sequel. It pairs its harsh verdict with details of violence and the mismatch between Fincher and Tarantino.

How we sort sources into left, alternative and right →

Which coverage felt most fair?

One tap. No account needed.