Judge Lets Trump's $15 Billion Defamation Suit Against New York Times Proceed
Photo: The GuardianA federal judge in Tampa, Florida, on Thursday allowed President Donald Trump's $15 billion defamation lawsuit against The New York Times and Penguin Random House to proceed. Judge Steven Merryday dismissed two of the claims but let the core defamation allegations move forward, a partial win for Trump in his legal campaign against news outlets. The suit accuses three Times reporters, Susanne Craig, Russ Buettner and Peter Baker, of publishing false statements in two articles and the 2024 book Lucky Loser, which Craig and Buettner co-wrote. Trump says the material damaged his businesses and personal reputation. The court had earlier tossed an 80-page complaint for lacking a concise summary and containing heated language; an amended 40-page version filed in October dropped references to the 2024 election. The Times and Penguin deny defaming Trump and say in a court filing that the case is legally flawed and aimed at scoring political points.
Right-leaning sources, led by The Daily Signal, open with the book's suggestion that Trump likely committed tax crimes and present the suit as moving forward. Left-leaning sources, including The Guardian, lead with the partial dismissal and the Times' denial, while Raw Story's headline says the newspaper's defense collapsed. Variety and Al Jazeera add the finding of a plausible recklessness claim over tax fraud, and Al Jazeera notes critics call such suits attacks on a free press. The sides agree on the core facts but differ on emphasis: the right centers the tax-crime allegation, the left the Times' rebuttal.
How the sides differ Right sources stress the book's tax-crime suggestion; left and alternative sources lead with the partial ruling and Times denials.
Headline, comparison and summary written by AI from the articles below. AI can make mistakes, so check the original articles before relying on a detail.
Word choice
The words each side uses for the same thing, taken from their articles.
- the lawsuitLeft “defamation lawsuit”Right “libel suit”
- the amount soughtLeft “$15bn”Right “$15 Billion”
- Raw StoryNYT's 'smells like a crime' defense collapses in Trump's $15 billion defamation lawsuit
- The New RepublicTrump’s $10 Billion BBC Lawsuit Is Massively Blowing Up in His Face
Leads with the judge's partial ruling and the Times' denials that the case has merit. Raw Story's headline says the Times' defense collapsed.
- Al JazeeraTrump’s case against NYT and Penguin Random House may proceed: Judge
- The HillJudge rules Trump's defamation case against New York Times, Penguin Random House may proceed
Focuses on the finding of a plausible recklessness claim about tax fraud. Al Jazeera also highlights critics who call the suits attacks on a free press.
- NewsmaxTrump Scores Legal Victory Against New York Times, Judge Allows Key Defamation Claims to Proceed
Highlights the book's suggestion that Trump likely committed tax crimes. Presents the libel suit as moving forward.
How we sort sources into left, alternative and right →
Which coverage felt most fair?
One tap. No account needed.