Mamdani Signs Law Ending NYC Horse-Drawn Carriages by June 2028
Photo: The Guardian USNew York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani signed legislation Thursday ending the city's 150-year horse-drawn carriage industry by June 1, 2028. Roughly 200 workers will be affected, and the city will offer them medallion buybacks, career services and workforce development, according to the mayor's website. Mamdani first announced the plan in October after a deal with the City Council speaker, and the carriages had drawn criticism over the horses' well-being. The bill, Romanch's Law, is named for Romanch Mahajan, an 18-year-old tourist who died in June after falling from a runaway carriage in Central Park when the horse bolted. A full dismantling plan, which will factor in feedback from carriage workers, is due in April 2027.
Left-leaning outlets in this set had not reported the carriage law at the time of writing; their one article here, from The New York Times, covers a DealBook conversation with Mamdani about the midterms, Trump and a “tax the rich” video. Alternative outlets had not covered it either: Reason wrote about Lina Khan's appointment to lead the city's economic development agency, and CNBC wrote about Amazon warning of higher delivery costs. Right-leaning outlets are therefore the only ones covering the carriage ban. Washington Examiner leads with the 150-year tradition and the roughly 200 workers, and features Trump's Truth Social post, which called the closure “based largely on one tragic accident.” Newsmax keeps it brief, framing the law as a ban that retires a Central Park attraction, and its excerpt does not mention the workers or Trump. Both right-leaning outlets agree on the signing and the 2028 deadline.
How the sides differ Only right-leaning sources cover the carriage law, stressing the 150-year tradition and Trump's criticism; left and alternative sources had not reported it.
Headline, comparison and summary written by AI from the articles below. AI can make mistakes, so check the original articles before relying on a detail.
- The New York TimesPaywallMamdani Talks Trump, Taxes and Oct. 7 at DealBook Summit
Washington Examiner leads with the 150-year tradition and Trump's criticism, while Newsmax frames it as a ban that retires a Central Park attraction. Both report the signing and the timeline.
How we sort sources into left, alternative and right →
Which coverage felt most fair?
One tap. No account needed.